The Ohio Attorney General and a Cleveland Judge are taking a stand against robo signers. The issue started when James Renfro's home was being foreclosed by Ally Financial Inc.'s GMAC Mortgage unit. Two affidavits submitted in Renfro's foreclosure case were signed by "Jeffery Stephan a GMAC employee who said in sworn depositions in Florida and Maine that he hadn't read thousands of affidavits he'd signed."

Ohio AG Richard  Cordray asked Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas Judge Nancy Russo to not let GMAC off easy by allowing them to simply submit new documents without consequences. Cordray also indicated "This is just the first".

The judge in Cleveland set an accelerated schedule on Monday for evidence-gathering in the case, leading up to a Feb. 17 hearing on the integrity of the loan documents. Cordray's office plans to file a motion today asking to take part in the case and participate in so-called discovery.

Perjury by False Affidavit is a crime. A felony in fact. All these robo signers and the lenders and attorneys that knew what they were doing were committing a crime.

Perjury in civil cases seems to rarely be enforced but there are instances where it has.  The local District Attorney would have to choose to prosecute.

I wonder if the Judge can also issue a contempt of court order? Knowingly submitting thousands of false affidavits seems like an attempt to impede the court's duties to this non legal expert.

The effect of this action in Ohio could have broad implications. Yesterday I posted how State Bank Regulators were denied help from the Office of the Comptroller of Currency  when they wanted to look into the foreclosure operations of some of the largest banks. The State's inquiries could have exposed robo signer's three years ago.

State regulators and the OCC, which regulates national banks, frequently butt heads over jurisdiction. Unfortunately the OCC has prevailed when the States have tried to intervened. If the OCC didn't intervene on behalf of the banks back in the early part of the century we might not have a predatory lending or subprime problems in NJ.

If the State regulators work with their respective AG's or DA's, it's possible they can regain some control over what banks are allowed to do in their States by prosecuting lenders and other parties for the crimes they committed. The OCC can't overrule AG's and DA's.

This type of pressure can persuade mortgage servicers to work on modifying loans instead of pushing them to go to foreclosure. Servicers are just the middlemen between borrowers and investors. Because the housing bubble finally burst and house values decreased significantly it's often better for the investors if the borrower makes lower payments rather than foreclosing. From More on the Mortgage Mess:

Take, for example, underwater borrowers — the millions of Americans who owe more on their loans than their homes are worth. For them, the best modification is often to reduce the loan’s principal balance, lowering the monthly payment and restoring some equity. That could be best for investors too, because even reduced payments are often better than a foreclosure sale. A bank’s servicing fee is based on the principal balances of the loan — a strong incentive not to reduce a troubled borrower’s balance.

Thanks to Mike Konczal's post which helped me find that article.


Those responsible for these robo-signing fraud must get what they deserve. Having these families out in the streets is really such a disgrace for them, knowing that they just deserve more review for their foreclosure issues..

Posted by las vegas foreclosures on November 24, 2011 at 10:34 AM EST #

Post a Comment:
Comments are closed for this entry.
[This is a Roller site]
Receive Free Updates
Enter your email address:
Delivered by FeedBurner

Recent Posts

  • Week of November 29, 2010 Foreclosure Auction Sales

    December 06, 2010

    A number of properties were sold last week at Sheriff Sale foreclosure auctions. All of them well below the judgment price. 31 B South Maple Ave, Park Ridge NJ -  had a winning bid of $57,600,…
  • What is Quantitative Easing :

    November 13, 2010

    Somehow hearing Quantitative Easing explained by cute cuddly cartoon characters doesn't seem so bad. Very good work by malekanoms regarding QE and related issues. See the video below.
  • River Vale Buys a Foreclosed Country Club

    November 10, 2010

    Did you see the foreclosure listing for 660 Rivervale Rd, River Vale, NJ and think to yourself "hey! I have $6.6 million laying around I think I'll pick myself up a country club at the Sheriff…
  • Consequences for Using Robo Signers May Be Coming

    November 09, 2010

    The Ohio Attorney General and a Cleveland Judge are taking a stand against robo signers . The issue started when James Renfro's home was being foreclosed by Ally Financial Inc.'s GMAC Mortgage unit.…
  • Should State Regulators Have More Power Over Banks

    November 08, 2010

    Could this whole housing bubble including the nationwide foreclosure mess have been avoided or at least been arrested before things got so out of hand? According to the article Regulators flawed in…
  • Week of October 25 Auction Results

    November 01, 2010

    It's been a while since I've posted an auction results report, ever since I added the functionality to view previous auctions on the site but it's been a while since I blogged anything so here are 4…
  • Centuria Project Up For Auction?

    February 07, 2009

    I've been busy improving the site and I can't believe I missed this listing yesterday. A notice of sale was issued for a property in Fort Lee, NJ with a judgment of $31,342,684.70. The address of…
  • Monmouth County and Morris County Foreclosures

    February 05, 2009

    This week, 2 additional NJ Counties were added to the site. You can now find Morris County foreclosures and  Monmouth County foreclosures on this site. Adding more counties has been…
  • January 23, 2009 Sheriff Auction Sales

    January 26, 2009

    Click here for current Bergen County Sheriff Sale listings as well as sheriff listings for other counties such as Monmouth, Middlesex, and Passaic. Twelve properties had been scheduled for last…
  • January 16, 2009 Sheriff Auction Sales

    January 20, 2009

    28 properties were scheduled for last Friday's foreclosure auction, 3 were sold out of the 10 that were put on auction. Two were sold below the awarded foreclosure judgment. 67 Willow Ave,…